Valdosta Daily Times

Top News

September 8, 2010

Student wins suit against former VSU president

VALDOSTA — A former Valdosta State University student has won a legal battle against past university president Dr. Ronald Zaccari.

The lawsuit stems from a 2007 incident involving a protest against proposed parking garages at Valdosta State University and the president’s decision to “administratively withdraw” the student leading the protest.

The federal court judge, Charles A. Pannell Jr., determined on Sept. 3, that Zaccari violated Hayden Barnes’ due process rights, with the former president being held personally liable for the damages.

The court also determined that the Board of Regents for the University System of Georgia violated a contract between Barnes and the board.

“Being president of Valdosta State University carried with it the awesome responsibility of looking out for the safety, welfare, and well-being of the thousands of students whose care was entrusted to us while at the same time fostering an environment of learning and achievement,” Zaccari said. “The action I took, coming less than three weeks after the tragedy of Virginia Tech, was solely motivated by my commitment to protect the safety of VSU students and the VSU campus.”  The lawsuit was filed in early 2008, after Barnes was reinstated by the Board of Regents.

Within the lawsuit, filed Jan. 9, 2008, Barnes levied seven counts against the university, specific university personnel and the Board of Regents of the University System of Georgia, two of which were dismissed.  

The remaining claims include liability regarding a free speech clause violation, liability regarding violation of  substantive and procedural due process rights, breach of contract, an Americans with Disabilities Act claim, and Rehabilitation Act claim.

On Sept. 3, the judge dismissed VSU as a defendant in the action and cleared all other VSU personnel of any wrongdoing.


Barnes became a student at VSU in the fall of 2005, an enrollment that would end with the transfer student on academic probation. He would re-enroll in 2007.

During re-enrollment, Barnes contacted the VSU Access Office to register on-campus as a disabled student suffering from panic disorder and agoraphobia. Through this Barnes was permitted extra time for test-taking and authorized a private dorm room, according to court documents.

In the spring of 2007, Barnes was prompted to voice his displeasure about a proposed $30 million construction of parking decks on VSU by circulating information and flyers across campus.

Barnes felt the construction project could be damaging to the environment, also posting information about the subject on his Facebook account.

According to court documents, Barnes was notified by members of Students Against Violating the Environment (S.A.V.E.) in March of 2007 that Zaccari was upset with Barnes’ actions.

In response, Barnes removed the flyers and deleted entries on his Facebook page. The student also wrote a letter to Zaccari stating he would remove the flyers and did not want an adverse response to his actions, according to court documents.

Barnes continued to protest the development by creating a  collage that contained images of a multi-level parking structure, a bull-dozer, a globe flattened tire tread, an asthma inhaler, a photo of Zaccari and a picture of a public bus with a red circle and slash across it. It also included slogans that stated “more smog,” “bus system that might have been,” “climate change statement for President Zaccari” and “S.A.V.E. — Zaccari Memorial Parking Garage.”

He also began contacting Board of Regents members when he learned they would vote on the proposed development at VSU in April of 2007.

According to court documents, one of the board members received an e-mail from Barnes, which she forwarded to Zaccari along with the concern that Barnes would show up at the board meeting. The board member requested that the possibility of a protest be handled at a campus level.

The day before the board meeting, Barnes met with Zaccari and Russ Mast, then the university’s dean of students. Zaccari expressed his displeasure with Barnes’ protest activities, according to court documents.

Following the meeting on April 19, 2007, The Spectator, the university’s student newspaper, published a letter written by Barnes, in which he expressed his views regarding the parking deck.

An investigation into Barnes quickly unfolded with Zaccari and other VSU administrative staff holding several meetings between April 20 and May 7, 2007, to discuss Barnes.

The meetings would include at various times Laverne Gaskins, in-house counsel, Kurt Keppler, then vice president for Student Affairs, Mast, and Leah McMillian, a counselor at VSU’s Student Counseling Center and a counselor in direct contact with Barnes.

Throughout all meetings in which McMillian attended, she repeatedly stated that Barnes was not a threat to himself or others, according to court documents. McMillian stated that she had “never at anytime observed any behaviors that warranted (her) being concerned that Mr. Barnes was a threat to himself or anyone else.”

During another meeting with Richard Lee, VSU assistant dean of students, and Keppler, none of Barnes’ activities were in violation of the VSU student code.

At an April staff meeting that included VSU Police Major Ann Farmer, Zaccari stated that an intruder had tripped the alarm at his home and that he had been receiving crank calls from a male caller at his home phone.

 On April 26, 2007, in a meeting with Keppler, McMillian and Dr. Victor Morgan of the VSU counseling center, Zaccari reiterated his concern regarding Barnes and claimed he felt threatened for his own safety and for that of the VSU campus. He then discussed the possibility of using an “administrative withdrawal” to remove Barnes from campus, according to court documents.

During the meeting, Zaccari described Barnes’ collage as “an indirect threat” on him, but none of those in attendance expressed agreement with Zaccari’s concern.

In the court documents, Zaccari expressed his feelings of an “indirect threat” by stating that Barnes had posted comments about the president on his Facebook page and had posted an article regarding the mass shooting at Virginia Tech.

Morgan felt Barnes was not using memorial in a threatening manner but took it to mean “this is a building that is going to be designated with your name on it, that you’re going to be held responsible for the parking garage,” according to court documents.

The following day, Zaccari employed a personal security team from VSU police for protection as he felt Barnes would ultimately personally attack him.

In late April, Zaccari requested that Gaskins inquire about a student’s appeal rights if a university president files a complaint against a student for violation of the student code of conduct.

Gaskins contacted Elizabeth Neely, vice chancellor for legal affairs at the Board of Regents, who responded via e-mail, “In this case, the appeal should be directed straight to our office. It is not good practice for the president to be bringing a complaint against any student. That should be handled by staff in Student Affairs. Once the President has made a decision in the matter, there is no due process at the campus level.”

On May 2, 2007, Neely discussed various ways Barnes could be administratively withdrawn with Zaccari and Gaskins.

According to court documents, Gaskins expressed concern that any withdrawal might be in violation of his rights under the First Amendment, the due process clause and/or the Americans with Disabilities Act.

Later, Neely told Zaccari that he should focus on the safety of the campus and himself and “we’ll worry about the lawsuit later,” according to court documents.

During this time, McMillian continued to meet with Barnes, who was also seen by his psychiatrist in Savannah. During a session with McMillian on April 27, 2007, Barnes said that he had made no direct or indirect threats to (the) president and that he “would not harm self or others.”

On April 30, 2007, following a session with his psychiatrist, Barnes’ medication to target his symptoms of anxiety, depression and obsessiveness was increased. The psychiatrist also sent a letter to McMillian stating that “there was nothing during the interview that led me to think that (Barnes) was a danger to himself or others.”

During a May 3, 2007, meeting, Zaccari stated that under Board of Regents policy 1902, he had the authority to unilaterally decide to “withdraw any student from campus if he feels they pose a danger and that he planned to administratively withdraw Mr. Barnes.”

Both Keppler and Gaskins expressed concerns about the withdrawal during the meeting — Keppler on the grounds that the counseling center had given no reason to withdraw Barnes for mental-health reasons and Gaskins on the grounds that “a student accused of violating Board Policy 1902 is entitled to due process.”

On May 3, 2007, Zaccari directed Gaskins to draft the withdrawal notice. On the notice Gaskins reiterated that the student has a right to due process, the student be apprised of what particular policy has been violated, the student provided an opportunity to be heard and also informed of the appeal process.

The “administratively withdrawn” notice received by Barnes stated that to continue his enrollment at VSU he must submit a correspondence from a non-university appointed psychiatrist indicating that he was not a danger to himself or others and documentation from a certified mental health professional indicating that, during his time at VSU, Barnes would receive ongoing therapy.

Within one day, Barnes filed for reinstatement in accordance with the requirements; however, Zaccari determined that Barnes remained a danger to the VSU campus.

On May 9, Barnes was notified that he had 48 hours to vacate his residence hall room.

Text Only
Top News
  • Johnson family files second suit against school system

    Two months after filing a civil suit against Lowndes County Schools, Kendrick Johnson's parents have filed a second suit against the school system which again claims that negligence and bullying led to their son’s death.

    July 29, 2014

  • Bears spotted on Baytree Road

    A pair of bear sightings along Baytree Road could indicate a growing black bear population in Lowndes County.

    July 29, 2014

  • photo.JPG Dump truck suspects apprehended

    LCSO has apprehended both of the suspects believed to be connected with the theft of a dump truck in Macon on Monday.

    July 29, 2014 1 Photo

  • Dollar Tree-Family Do_Rich copy.jpg Dollar Tree buys Family Dollar

    The fight for penny pinchers is intensifying.

    July 29, 2014 1 Photo

  • APTOPIX Mideast Israe_Rich copy.jpg Gaza war rages despite Hamas, Israel truce pledges

    Israel and Hamas launched new attacks Sunday in the raging Gaza war, despite going back and forth over proposals for a temporary halt to nearly three weeks of fighting ahead of a major Muslim holiday.
    The failure to reach even a brief humanitarian lull in the fighting illustrated the difficulties in securing a more permanent truce as the sides remain far apart on their terms.

    July 29, 2014 1 Photo

  • Ga. woman sentenced in child abuse case

    The mother of a 1-year-old boy who was hospitalized with a fractured skull in 2012 has been sentenced to nine years in prison.

    July 29, 2014

  • AP81072904918 copy.jpg Today in History for Tuesday, July 29, 2014

    Today is Tuesday, July 29, the 210th day of 2014. There are 155 days left in the year.

    July 29, 2014 1 Photo

  • United Way presents fundraising prom

    Save the date — and make sure to find one — for The Prom, a retro-celebration to benefit the Greater Valdosta United Way.

    July 29, 2014

  • Times hosts blood drive

    The Valdosta Daily Times will participate in a blood drive, 12:30-5:30 p.m. Friday, Aug. 1, with the American Red Cross Bloodmobile visiting The Times’ 201 N. Troup St. parking lot.

    July 29, 2014

  • Free health fair planned for Quitman on Aug. 9

    A free health fair hosted by the 100 Black Men of Brooks-Grady-and-Thomas Counties, Inc. and sponsored by Archbold Hospital will take place Aug. 9  from 8 a.m.-noon. The second annual 100 B-G-T Health Fair will be located at the Courtland Avenue Church of Christ in Quitman. All Valdosta-Lowndes County residents are welcome to attend.

    July 29, 2014

Top News

Do you agree with the millage rate increases?

Yes. We need to maintain services
No. Services should have been cut.
     View Results