Valdosta Daily Times

Top News

April 11, 2012

Giant water agency approves rate hikes in S. Calif

SAN DIEGO — SAN DIEGO (AP) — California’s giant water wholesaler approved a smaller rate increase Tuesday than its staff proposed, but it wasn’t low enough to satisfy officials who claim a “shadow government” has seized control of the agency and is targeting consumers in San Diego.

The board of the Metropolitan Water District of Southern California approved 5 percent annual rate increases for each of the next two years after a highly unusual attack by the San Diego County Water Authority, the largest of its 26 customers.

San Diego claims Metropolitan’s rate structure is stacked against the nation’s eighth-largest city and its suburbs. The allegation was the basis of a lawsuit it filed in 2010 in state court.

San Diego wanted to limit annual rate increases to 3 percent.

San Diego launched a website last month to lift what it describes as a veil of secrecy at Metropolitan, its largest supplier. The site offers a trove of internal documents obtained under California’s public records law, including references to a “Secret Society” and an “anti-San Diego coalition.”

Metropolitan has demanded San Diego remove Metropolitan’s defaced seal from the new website, The seal is altered to read, “The Truth About the Metropolitan Water District of So. Cal.”

Some speakers at Tuesday’s rate hearing criticized San Diego’s tactics.

“The core of these allegations is that (Metropolitan) staff has met and somehow controlled the Met board,” said Paul Jones, general manager of Eastern Municipal Water District, which serves the distant eastern suburbs of Los Angeles. “These allegations are not only baseless but an affront to the integrity of this board.”

Thomas Wornham, the San Diego agency’s vice chairman, gave faint praise to the more modest rate hike. It shaved the 2013 increase to 5 percent from the 7.5 percent that Metropolitan’s staff proposed.

“It’s just not good enough when it’s so clear that this board can do better,” Wornham said before the vote.

The rate increases were approved as part of Metropolitan’s two-year budget — $1.78 billion for 2013 and $1.89 billion for 2014.

The bad blood dates back to a drought in the early 1990s, when San Diego began a drive to become less dependent on Metropolitan. Dennis Cushman, the San Diego agency’s assistant general manager, said the region then got 95 percent of its water from Metropolitan and now gets less than half.

As with many water disputes in arid stretches of the West, this one is just as much about how to move water from one place to another as it is about the water itself. San Diego lacks its own water supply and — just as importantly — doesn’t own pipes to get it from somewhere else.

In 2003, San Diego agreed to buy a big chunk of its water from California’s Imperial Valley in the nation’s largest farm-to-city water transfer. But it still needs Metropolitan’s 242-mile aqueduct to carry the water from the Colorado River.

The same year, Metropolitan introduced a rate structure that levies one fee for transporting water and another for the water itself. The San Diego agency alleges the transportation fee includes lots of unrelated costs, amounting to San Diego subsidizing other agencies that buy water directly from Metropolitan.

Metropolitan, whose customers include cities and water agencies serving 19 million people in six counties, defends the new rate structure and accuses San Diego of trying to unload costs on others. It suggests San Diego overpaid for Imperial Valley’s water and is trying to make up for a bad business decision.

The stakes are so high that many Metropolitan member agencies began meeting in 2009 to discuss San Diego’s challenge to the rate structure and other issues. San Diego says it didn’t learn the group existed until after a request for public records last October that has produced more than 60,000 pages of documents.

The San Diego County Water Authority says the documents show the group met up to 60 times and alleges that members coordinated votes with Metropolitan’s board of directors, which would potentially violate the state’s open-meetings law. The documents show the group paid for advice from a consulting firm that employs Ron Gastelum, a former Metropolitan general manager.

Two emails from one participant — Chris Theisen, assistant director of public works for Beverly Hills — refer to the group as the “Secret Society.” Handwritten notes from one meeting mention the “anti-San Diego coalition.”

San Diego packaged the documents in thick binders and sent them to reporters throughout California under the heading, “Who really runs the Metropolitan Water District of Southern California? A shadow government takes control.”

Metropolitan says there is nothing unusual about staff from member agencies getting together to discuss issues. In addition, it adamantly denies the group is a forum to coordinate board votes.

Text Only
Top News
  • blood drive.jpg Give Blood

    Give Blood

    August 1, 2014 1 Photo

  • Man arrested in Valdosta drug raid

    Man arrested in Valdosta drug raid

    August 1, 2014

  • Taiwan Gas Explosions_Stew.jpg Gas explosions in Taiwan

    At least 24 people were killed and 271 others injured when several underground gas explosions ripped through Taiwan’s second-largest city overnight, hurling concrete through the air and blasting long trenches in the streets, authorities said Friday.

    August 1, 2014 1 Photo

  • Immigration Overload_Roge.jpg Immigration courts speed up children’s cases

    Immigration courts are speeding up hearings for the tens of thousands of Central American children caught on the U.S. border after criticism that the backlogged system is letting immigrants stay in the country for years while waiting for their cases to be heard.

    August 1, 2014 1 Photo

  • Extra jurors seated for long Ga. salmonella trial

    After three days of jury selection, a panel with plenty of extra members was seated Thursday to hear the case of three people charged in connection with a deadly salmonella outbreak traced to a southwest Georgia peanut plant five years ago.

    August 1, 2014

  • Liberia West Africa E_Roge.jpg Ebola outbreak tops 700 deaths

    The death toll from the worst recorded Ebola outbreak in history surpassed 700 in West Africa as security forces went house-to-house in Sierra Leone’s capital Thursday looking for patients and others exposed to the disease.

    August 1, 2014 1 Photo

  • Mideast Israel Palest_Roge.jpg U.S., U.N. announce deal on Gaza cease-fire

    Israel and Hamas have agreed to a 72-hour humanitarian cease-fire beginning Friday, during which time there will be negotiations on a more durable truce in the 24-day-old Gaza war, the United States and United Nations announced Thursday.

    August 1, 2014 1 Photo

  • APTOPIX Congress_Stew.jpg Congress oks VA, highway bills, not border measure

    Congress ran full-tilt into election-year gridlock over immigration Thursday and staggered toward a five-week summer break after failing to agree on legislation to cope with the influx of young immigrants flocking illegally to the United States.

    August 1, 2014 1 Photo

  • Wisconsin Unions_Stew.jpg Wisconsin Supreme Court upholds union law

    The fight over Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker’s signature policy achievement, a law effectively ending collective bargaining for most public employees, ended Thursday with the state Supreme Court declaring it to be constitutional.

    August 1, 2014 1 Photo

  • Today in History

    In 1714, Britain's Queen Anne died at age 49; she was succeeded by George I.

    August 1, 2014

Top News

Do you agree with the millage rate increases?

Yes. We need to maintain services
No. Services should have been cut.
     View Results