Valdosta Daily Times

Local Sports

January 9, 2014

A rookie voter’s take on the Hall of Fame election

New York — There is a wonderful scene near the end of the movie “Charlie Wilson’s War” in which Philip Seymour Hoffman tells Tom Hanks the tale of the Zen master and the little boy.

Among the lessons in that little yarn about life’s ever-changing uncertainty is this: Every action has consequences — often unintended ones. Sometimes those consequences don’t become clear until years, decades, even generations later. But everything leads to something else.

You can count on it, like Greg Maddux’s pinpoint control.

———

The Steroids Era isn’t over.

Not by a long shot.

Some of the annoying aftereffects are just starting to roll around, infesting the Hall of Fame ballot and turning quaint, little, old Cooperstown into baseball’s biggest battleground, a most imperfect contradiction rather than “America’s Most Perfect Village.”

And you know what? Accept it. This is a big part of what PEDs have wrought.

Consequences. Messy consequences embarrassing to baseball. The game earned every last one of them.

So Maddux, Tom Glavine and Frank Thomas got in Wednesday, while Craig Biggio barely missed and Jack Morris fell short in his final try on the Baseball Writers’ Association of America ballot.

Voters remained mostly split on sluggers Mike Piazza and Jeff Bagwell. Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens — not even close.

In reality, these broiling, never-ending debates were born decades ago. There’s no way Hall of Fame elections could be neat and clean once even a handful of players were dirty.

———

As a first-time voter, I consider it an honor and a privilege to have one voice in the process. I thought long and hard about my initial choices — for years, really — and discussed them with practically anyone who was interested.

Probably a few people who weren’t, too.

When I was younger, of course, I never imagined I’d be contemplating court documents, congressional testimony and grand jury indictments. Just the numbers on the backs of all those baseball cards I collected, and my memories of a shortstop ranging deep into the hole.

But by the time I came to bat last month, the task was much tougher: A ballot overstuffed with worthy candidates, many of them holdovers stained by steroids allegations. The maximum is 10 selections, and the six specific criteria include integrity, sportsmanship and character.

After much deliberation, I checked eight boxes: Bagwell, Glavine, Maddux, Mike Mussina, Piazza, Tim Raines, Curt Schilling and Thomas.

I have my reasons and rationale, like all voters. I accept that one or more of my picks may have used steroids or other illegal drugs. I’m well aware of the giants I left off. I wish it wasn’t that way.   

———

The hard truth is, there’s no sure way to know which stars compiled authentic statistics and which resumes were artificially inflated. Whether that should even matter at this point is a reasonable question.

But the integrity of the Hall of Fame, just like the game itself, was compromised the moment players began juicing and nobody did anything to nip it in the bud.

Blame it on the guys who used and got rich. Blame it on the clean ones who kept quiet for too long. Blame it on the commissioners or owners who looked the other way as the money rolled in. Blame it on the media if you want, for playing the fool and missing the story until it was way too late.

Doesn’t matter. There’s no going back now.

Players who cheated are going to wind up in the Hall of Fame.

It may have happened already.

Deserving men will be denied, due (at least partly) to unfounded suspicions or overcrowded ballots.

Many think that happened again Wednesday.

Unfortunately, no unsullied solution exists. Not anymore.

And anyone who cares about this sort of thing, from Major League Baseball headquarters to the Hall of Fame hopefuls themselves, from the voters who have a voice to the die-hard fans who don’t, will have to live with those consequences.

1
Text Only
Local Sports
  • Nolin settling in as new VSU soccer coach

    Meet Rebecca Nolin, VSU's new soccer coach.

    July 28, 2014

  • Induction Crowd: Honorees were genuine, down to earth

    More than 48,000 people gathered under the scorching sun at The Clark Sports Center for the 75th National Baseball Hall of Fame Induction Sunday, including one woman who carpooled to the event with more than 40 other people.

    July 28, 2014

  • Braves trio all business at inductions

    The Braves seemed almost businesslike in their approach -- something you might expect from a trio that won so consistently.
    Managers Joe Torre and Tony La Russa also remained calm and collected throughout their addresses.
    Frank Thomas took care of the emotional side, his voice breaking and his eyes moist during a heartfelt speech Sunday at the Clark Sports Center.
     

    July 28, 2014

  • Cooperstown Merchants: Weekend was a success

    Cooperstown merchants are elated about the exceptionally prosperous Hall of Fame Induction Weekend, several storekeepers said Sunday.

    During an afternoon lull in business, when the National Baseball Hall of Fame's induction ceremony was taking place, area shop and restaurant owners took a quick breath, reflected and expressed satisfaction with their sales for the weekend.
     

    July 28, 2014

  • Hall of Famers thank fathers for stepping up to the plate

    Great ballplayers thanking their dads at a Hall of Fame Induction Ceremony is about as original as oil and vinegar are to an Italian restaurant.

    July 28, 2014

  • Hall_Maddux.jpg Hall of Braves

    The weird part was that Jeff Idelson didn't take a lot of time to answer.
    "Is there any word or description that unifies this class?" was the query posed to the National Baseball Hall of Fame's president.
    "The common thread among the six is profound humility," Idelson said of former managers Joe Torre, Bobby Cox and Tony La Russa, and former players Frank Thomas, Greg Maddux and Tom Glavine, all of whom will be inducted into the Hall today. "I don't think I realized that fully until I spent time with them in December. It was uncanny to me, for the cumulative star power in that group, the humility among them. I think that's felt really strongly with baseball fans."

    July 27, 2014 2 Photos 1 Story

  • Hall_Cox.jpg Cox’s willingness to defend players stands out to local coaches

    Bobby Cox will be able to add Hall of Famer to his resume when he is inducted into the National Baseball Hall of Fame today in Cooperstown, N.Y.
    But the former Atlanta Braves manager’s legacy will remain the same to area baseball coaches: his willingness to defend his players.

    July 27, 2014 1 Photo 1 Story

  • Valwood_Henderson.jpg Area teams hoping to get over the hump

    Past successes lead to present and future expectations.
    That’s the task faced by pretty much all 12 area high school football coaches present Saturday at In The Game Magazine’s South Georgia Football media day at the Holiday Inn conference center.
    It’s a task that also has the elite group searching for answers as to how to get past the state championship road block in recent years, aside from Valwood’s GISA Class AA crown in 2012.

    July 27, 2014 1 Photo

  • VHS little cats camp 1.jpg Valdosta hosts fundamental camp for ‘Little ’Cats’

    July 27, 2014 1 Photo

  • VHS practice1.jpg Getting Back to Work

    Friday officially began the 2014 season for the Valdosta Wildcats and both the offense and defense came out and made statements.
    After holding spring and summer workouts, the Wildcats will practice four more times without pads before beginning full pad practice next week.

    July 26, 2014 2 Photos

Blazers Blog
More