Valdosta Daily Times

Local News

May 18, 2012

Appeals court rules against Sheriff Prine

Lawsuit by fired employees given green light to go to trial

VALDOSTA — U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit overturned Tuesday a federal judge’s decision to dismiss a suit against Lowndes County and Sheriff Chris Prine, based on sufficient evidence to allow the case to go before a jury.

In 2011, federal Judge Hugh Lawson dismissed three former sheriff’s office employees’ claims they had been wrongly terminated by Prine.

Appeals court documents state the initial decision erred in finding that Prine and the county are entitled to Eleventh Amendment immunity, which rules that states are not immune from suits made by citizens of other states in federal courts and was later expanded in 1890 (Hans v. Louisiana) to include suits brought against a state by its own citizens.

The appeals court also ruled that the summary judgment was inappropriate because sufficient evidence was provided for a reasonable juror to conclude that the sheriff’s proffered reasons for the plaintiffs’ terminations were pretextual and were motivated by intentional discrimination.

“Basically the defendants presented a version of facts to the trial judge and we presented a version of facts that were supported by evidence,” plaintiffs attorney Harlan Miller told The Times Wednesday. “Basically, the judge disregarded or didn’t give much credence and basically accepted what the defendant said on every point.”

Miller stated that when conflicting evidence is presented, as occurred in 2011, a jury trial is the recommendation to sort through the differences.

“The sheriff will be the most unbelievable witness at his own trial. There’s no way he can get up at the trial and stand up to cross examination,” said Miller. “He basically retracted everything he said everywhere and left himself open for a lot of inconsistencies.”

No court date has been established.

Miller confirmed that settlements had been discussed between parties prior to the 2011 trial, but said the offer provided by the county and sheriff’s office were not reasonable. Miller said his clients have requested they be reinstated in the same capacity at the sheriff’s office and be paid their lost salaries.

Neither county officials nor Prine offered any comment on the appeal decision or case.

Rick Strickland, the sheriff’s attorney, did not respond to requests for comment by The Times.

Thomas Crews, Leanne Bennett and Michelle Keene were employed at Lowndes County Sheriff’s Office and allege that Prine wrongfully terminated their employment because they supported the sheriff’s opponent during the 2008 campaign for sheriff, according to court documents. The allegations made by the trio included wrongful termination based on sex, pregnancy, disability, age, former complaints of discrimination and for requesting time off from work.

Keene, who was a captain at the time, led the Jail Operations Division; Crews, a former lieutenant, worked in investigations; and Bennett, ranked as sergeant, supervised the K-9 unit. Bennett’s husband also worked at the sheriff’s office and supervised Bennett, and she is the sister of J.D. Yeager, Prine’s 2008 opponent for sheriff. All three were said to have supported Yeager’s candidacy for sheriff. The court document stated that after Prine assumed the position of sheriff, all three were terminated.

Prine assumed office at midnight on Jan. 1, 2009. According to previous Times reports based on court documents, Crews was fired Dec. 31, 2008, because Crews “talked bad about Prine in Lake Park during the campaign” and openly campaigned against him. Prine admitted in 2011 that this was partly the reason behind the termination.

In 2000, Crews received knee-replacement surgery and was unable to run or stand for long periods of time. Prine testified that he had someone else in mind that he wanted in Crews’ position, that “he knew Crews had a gambling problem and that his length of service was a reason to terminate him,” according to court papers.

Leanne Bennett campaigned for her brother, Yeager, during the 2008 election and Prine stated that at a community event, the two had gotten into a disagreement.

On Jan. 2, 2009, Prine terminated Bennett’s employment because “he needed loyal people to work for him.” Bennett asked if she could be transferred to a different unit that was not under leadership from her husband and Prine denied the opportunity. Bennett was seven months pregnant and submitted a request for maternity leave and alleged that her termination violated her right to freedom of political and familial association, her right to be free from gender and pregnancy discrimination.

  In the case of Keene, she began working for the sheriff’s office in 1994. She received a series of promotions and favorable annual performance evaluations. She had never received a written reprimand for deficient performances. In court documents, the complaints on Bennett and those made by Bennett started during the 2008 campaign.

  Prine terminated her on Oct. 26, 2009. Prine stated in a termination letter that it was due to her “insufficient leadership and performance as a supervisor.” Keene claims she was terminated because of her gender and in retaliation for complaining about Prine’s discriminatory actions; also because she supported Yeager during the 2008 campaign.

 

1
Text Only
Local News
  • 140415-water003.jpg Sewage problems persist

    Early Tuesday morning, Valdosta became saturated when the area received approximately three inches of rain from 4 a.m. to noon. As of 3 p.m. Tuesday, 11 manholes throughout the City of Valdosta have spilled 286,500 gallons of wastewater into local waterways, and this number will continue to rise.

    April 16, 2014 2 Photos

  • vsuopera1dido.jpg Operatic Conclusion

    When the curtain lowers this weekend on Valdosta State University Opera’s performance of Henry Purcell’s “Dido and Aeneas,” it will not only mark the end of the music group’s season.

    April 16, 2014 2 Photos

  • ‘If I Were Mayor’ contest essays

    If I were mayor, I would do all that I possibly can to make the city of Valdosta marvelous, but I cannot do it on my own. Some things in Valdosta I feel it is necessary to focus on would be our literacy rate, unemployment rate, crime history, and our environment.

    April 16, 2014

  • APTOPIX Boston Marath_Stew.jpg Solemn tributes mark Boston Marathon bombing

    Survivors, first responders and relatives of those killed in the Boston Marathon bombing marked the anniversary Tuesday with tributes that combined sorrow over the loss of innocent victims with pride over the city’s resilience in the face of a terror attack.

    April 16, 2014 1 Photo

  • 140414-valdostaboe001 copy.jpg Valdosta Board of Education reviews finances

    Valdosta City Schools Board of Education celebrated many successes Monday night, discussed budget information and heard an announcement of intent from a hopeful charter school.

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • dancing with the stars copy.jpg Dancing with Valdosta Stars raises scholarship money

    Valdosta State University Music and Theatre & Dance’s Third Annual Dancing with the Stars of Valdosta presented a fine dance show this past weekend.

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • N0041120.jpg Passover: A nation reborn

    “And you shall tell your children that on that day the Lord has took you out from the house of bondage.” — The Passover Hagadah

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • 140414-DFCS001.jpg Luncheon recognizes DFACS employees

    Dozens of Lowndes County Division of Family and Children Services employees gathered Monday at Olympic Park for a barbecue lunch in recognition of their hard work.

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • 140414-Sewage002.jpg Fla. calls for Valdosta boycott

    Florida residents are calling for a boycott of Valdosta regarding the sewage spills, with areas affected downstream increasingly distressed over the millions of gallons that have polluted the waters of the Withlacoochee and the Suwannee River Basin during the last several years.

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • police-lights-backgrounds-for-powerpoint.jpg ‘Dangerous’ fugitive caught

    A fugitive from Ohio wanted for attempted murder and a number of assault and robbery charges was captured by Valdosta police Saturday.

    April 14, 2014 2 Photos

Top News
Poll

What you think about school and workplace rules about Facebook friends?

There have to be rules.
No need for rules, just use common sense.
If people want to be friends, what is the big deal?
Nobody uses Facebook anymore.
     View Results