Valdosta Daily Times

Local News

March 10, 2013

FEMA denies funding request

City’s application for $94 million turned down; appeals denied

VALDOSTA — The City of Valdosta applied to the Federal Emergency Management Agency in 2009 requesting assistance to relocate and rebuild the Withlacoochee Wastewater Treatment Plant (WWTP), also referred to as the Pollution Control Plant (WPCP). According to a letter from FEMA in December 2010, the agency presented three mitigation proposals:

1. Relocate the facility at an estimated cost of $94 million.

2. Construct an earthen berm around certain portions of the facility, construct a stormwater collection and pumping station within areas behind the berm, and construct an effluent pumping station to discharge effluent during flooding events at a cost of approximately $4.1 million.

3. Construct flood barriers around the chlorine and dewatering buildings, construct a flood barrier around the influent pump station, place dewatering pumps within the areas behind the berm, and increase the height of the tertiary filtration system walls to five feet at a cost of approximately $1.1 million.

The letter states that the city has “indicated they want to relocate the facility and do not wish to pursue options two and three.”

According to the FEMA letter, following the April 2009 flood event, they prepared a project worksheet in the amount of $527,183.70 to document identified damages and estimated repairs to the plant. Also, a proposed floodwall around the plant at a cost of $33 million was not cost effective.

FEMA denied the city’s application for the $94 million cost to relocate and rebuild the plant on the basis that it wasn’t cost effective and applied to undamaged elements of the facility. The city appealed the decision in February 2011.

According to documents obtained in an open records request, the appeal was based on the fact that the local Lowndes County ULDC (Unified Land Development Code) and flood-plain ordinances, along with International Building Codes and FEMA’s own flood-plain management directives prohibit the city from making substantial improvements or repairs at the current location.

In the appeal letter, Deputy City Manager John Whitehead states, “The declared event was not the first, nor the only time the WPCP has flooded. In fact, its low flood-plain elevation has led to a number of permit violations:

“Between October 1993 and August 2010, 21 separate events led to 123 total days of flood levels exceeding 122 feet or greater in elevation. This means the WPCP is under flooding an average of 7.2 days per year, including the 2009 declared event, which reached an elevation of 137 feet at maximum river stage.

“Each of these flooding events put the community at risk. Many flooding events resulted in the discharge of raw sewage outside the controlled system, threatening the health of the community and the integrity of the river, its ecosystem and other downstream persons and communities. The damage and the risks will continue unabated if significant hazard mitigation measures are not put in place.”

This first appeal was denied by FEMA again, according to FEMA documents, as it was not cost effective to spend $94 million when the plant sustained $527,000 in damages.

The city appealed the decision a second time in February 2012, this time requesting $88 million to relocate and rebuild the plant, and was again denied by FEMA in July 2012 citing FEMA’s Disaster Assistance Policy, Hazard Mitigation Funding Under Section 406 (Stafford Act), dated July 30, 2007.

The FEMA policy states, “If mitigation measures are approved for the repair of a disaster-damaged facility and the subgrantee requests an improved project which will instead involve the replacement of the facility, on the same site or an alternate site, the cost of the mitigation measures is not eligible.”

When asked if the city could find any other wastewater plant relocations that had been funded by FEMA, Whitehead said there were none, and the city’s would have been the first.

In an interview in February of this year prior to the current flooding event, city officials stated that despite the FEMA rejections, the plant has to be moved and the city has to find a way to pay for it out of local funds and a proposed SPLOST (special purpose local option sales tax). The figure to rebuild the plant is now roughly $20 million with an additional $32 million for a major force main project to replace the gravity lines, for which the city has obtained a $32 million GEFA loan.

City officials stated that the plant cannot be substantially repaired or improved in its current state as the county’s ULDC prohibits them from doing so since it’s in a flood plain. According to the county, the ULDC does prohibit it, but the city is also eligible to request a variance to make those repairs and has not done so.

1
Text Only
Local News
  • 140724-LAT1.jpg Little Actors Theatre ready for summer show

    Since 2004, the Little Actors Theatre has provided a place for children ages 6 to 19 to express themselves through acting.

    July 25, 2014 1 Photo

  • 072414-MichelleNunn003.jpeg Michelle Nunn visits Valdosta

    The day after learning that her Republican challenger would be David Perdue, Democratic U.S. Senate hopeful Michelle Nunn kicked off her Common Sense and Collaboration Tour Wednesday by meeting with business owners in Atlanta, Athens and Macon and continued her tour Thursday morning by visiting the David S. Waller Unit facility of the Boys and Girls Club of Valdosta.

    July 25, 2014 1 Photo

  • lunch.jpg Valdosta One Lunch feeds summer-hungry kids

    Hunger is a concept that many people associate with third-world countries, not their hometown. However, in Valdosta, hunger is real. To combat this hunger, a group of Valdostans have created Valdosta One Lunch, a program that distributes bagged meals to children in need.

    July 25, 2014 1 Photo

  • thumbs up.jpeg Moody squadron commander reaches milestone

    The 75th Fighter Squadron commander hit a career milestone July 17, by surpassing 3,000 flight hours in an A-10C Thunderbolt II.

    July 25, 2014 1 Photo

  • water.jpg New equipment expected to deal with Lowndes water violations

    The Lowndes County Commission’s recent approval of $1.6 million for water-treatment equipment is expected to counter a past series of water-quality violations within the county.

    July 25, 2014 1 Photo

  • 142314-Goodwill.jpg Goodwill hosts the Mexican Consulate

    Mexican citizens living in South Georgia have spent this week lining up at the Valdosta Goodwill to meet with the Mexican Consulate to obtain Mexican government issued identification.

    July 24, 2014 1 Photo

  • 140723-Tree001.jpg Chamber plants 100th centennial tree

    Founded in September 1912, the Valdosta-Lowndes County Chamber of Commerce is one of the largest chambers in the state.

    July 24, 2014 1 Photo

  • 140723 - Operation M#10E3C7.JPG Veterans First

    With Moody Air Force Base expecting to lose 300 to 400 personnel due to government cutbacks, area organizations are working with military personnel about to enter the civilian work force.

    July 24, 2014 2 Photos

  • Lowndes increases millage rate

    For the first time since 1999, the Lowndes County Commission voted Wednesday to increase the millage rate.

    July 24, 2014

  • dui memorial 1.jpg Memorial honors woman killed in DUI case

    More than a week after the man responsible for her death was sentenced to five years in jail, a memorial sign has been placed at the site where Sheila Foster-Lamb was hit and killed by an impaired driver while she was on her way to work.

    July 24, 2014 2 Photos

Top News
Poll

School starts again in about two weeks. What do you think?

It's still summer. School starts too soon.
Seems like the right time to return.
Abolish summer recess. Make school year-round.
     View Results